Back to News

Now Limited Protz Retroactivity in Workers’ Compensation Cases

Published on

June 16, 2020

When the Pennsylvania Supreme Court declared impairment rating evaluations (IREs) to be unconstitutional in the Protz case, it did not say anything about whether IREs conducted before the Protz decision were also invalid.

The Commonwealth Court has since held that claimants can challenge the validity of IREs at any time within three years of the last payment made, but the Pennsylvania Supreme Court has not yet ratified that relatively extreme position.

Until now. Though in a more limited fashion.

In Dana Corp. v. Workers’ Compensation Appeal Board (Smuck), decided today, the state’s highest court held that IREs pending on appeal at the time Protz was decided are invalid, as if they had never occurred, even if the constitutionality of the IRE was not at issue in the appeal. It is not clear how many cases will be affected by the ruling.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court explicitly left open the question whether Protz should be applied retroactively to cases never appealed or to cases fully litigated before Protz was decided. In that sense, employers and carriers have dodged a bullet for now. However, the court expressed sympathy for the position that Protz did not announce a “new rule of law,” suggesting that the court may in the future invalidate all IREs that occurred prior to 2017. Such a holding would surely open the floodgates to claims that most had thought were closed.

In 2018, Pennsylvania enacted a purported fix for Protz, and IREs conducted under the new statute then do not face the same constitutional hurdles as older IREs. The constitutionality of the new statute has not been tested.

If you have any questions about the Dana Corp. case or how it could affect your business, please contact me or Michael Crocenzi.


Related News

View More News
News Alert
July 24, 2025

The Limitations of E-Verify: What Employers Need to Know

Immigration laws require employers to ensure employees are legally authorized to work in the United States. Over the last few...

Learn More
News Alert
July 7, 2025

Planning for Immigration Enforcement Actions and Policy Changes: Best Practices for Employer Compliance and Response

This year, with the second Trump Administration well underway, the contours of different legal areas have undergone dramatic ...

Learn More
Press Release
June 25, 2025

Barley Snyder Attorney Andrew Mahon Appointed to American Immigration Lawyers Association 2026 Annual Conference Planning Committee

For Immediate Release Lancaster, Pa. – Barley Snyder attorney Andrew J. Mahon has been appointed to the American Immigratio...

Learn More

Get in Touch

Our attorneys, paralegals and staff look forward to hearing from you. Please reach out to let us know how we can help.

Get In Touch
RECOGNIZED IN
Super Lawyers
Best Law Firms US News
Best Lawyers