Back to News

When Retirement Isn’t Really Retirement: Pennsylvania Supreme Court Finds Early Retirees Eligible for Unemployment Compensation Benefits

Published on

February 23, 2013

In Diehl v. Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court recently ruled that early retirees are eligible for unemployment compensation benefits, reversing over 30 years of case law on the subject. In this case, Howard Diehl, a 63 year-old shipping clerk, accepted an early retirement package his employer offered as part of a program to avoid layoffs. The package included continuation of health insurance benefits and payment of unused vacation leave. Subsequently, Diehl filed for unemployment compensation benefits, but his claim was denied because Diehl voluntarily resigned without a necessitous and compelling reason. The Unemployment Compensation Board of Review and the Commonwealth Court upheld the denial.

On appeal, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court reversed, holding that the Unemployment Compensation Law’s definition of “layoff” could be interpreted to include the voluntary acceptance of an early retirement package. Consequently, employers considering early retirement programs should now factor in the costs of unemployment compensation claims. Employers can no longer defend claims by early retirees on the basis that they voluntarily left employment.

Barley Snyder’s Employment Law Group frequently counsels employers on early retirement programs and incentives. Please contact a member of our Employment Law Group if you would like assistance in structuring legally compliant retirement programs and incentives.

Related News

View More News
News Alert
August 1, 2022

EEOC: COVID-19 Screening Now Must Meet Business Necessity Test

Although COVID-19 still poses a threat to businesses and the public, the U....

Learn More
News Alert
June 23, 2022

EEOC Updates Guidance on Employer Use of Assessment Software, Algorithms and AI

On May 12, 2022, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) issued ...

Learn More
News Alert
May 25, 2022

Losing the Forest for the Trees: Third Circuit Reverses NLRB in ‘Joke’ v. ‘Threat’ ULP Case

It was all a joke. That’s what the Third Circuit Court of Appeals conclud...

Learn More

Get in Touch

Our attorneys, paralegals and staff look forward to hearing from you. Please reach out to let us know how we can help.

Get In Touch
Super Lawyers
Best Law Firms US News
Best Lawyers